rev., Feb 25, 2021.
Elizabeth, interloping in Eden’s hotel room,
sees that Eden has taped up a drawing her daughter made on the wall, to feel less homesick, so a tactic of creating a sense of being at home, or thinking of you. This is parallel to one I saw for the first time ever with The Little Things, on HBO, where Deke (Denzel) an old cop goes to an old hotel to stare at pictures of a suspect he puts up on the wall too, strange. It is also nicely contrasted, and this is good picture play, with another ersatz picture of a plantation, in the very art, large scale painting, in the room.
indeed, this IS picture play, in the sense that the movie is playing with pictures to create some ideas that push it along. I posted on it, since this is my balliwick, it could be said to be the flip mechanism of the movie
(since in first viewing I did not see this at all, I assume most viewers didn’t either; then I thought it, when it reappears in the cabin, might be a test card-like sign showing Eden how to do the flip; but, no, it is also an inosculation with her daughter by way of a children’s drawing she had in her hotel room earlier, it is as if the underscoring link between the two venues, and solves the problem).
Elizabeth then sabotages the room service, which Eden complains about at dinner, by flipping the sign on the door to do not disturb too
Then there is a strange encounter on the elevator. There is a little girl,
she looks pasty, and ghostly, dressed antiquely, and all about keeping quiet
the creepiest thing is that she drags a doll after her, on a rope, on the floor, like it was an abject slave, it is also gray, the color of the shadiness of the blinds
she sees the little girl in the corridor, it’s kind of creepy; then, hotel hallways, because of which hotel hallways are creepy, get quite long, scary
and way at the far, far end, far off, there is the little girl again, so Eden has an encounter with, as if, the twins of the Overlook hotel, some ghost child from the past of the site.
Who is this girl? a few possibilities. One, she is another appearance of the Soul Guide Girl that we saw in the opening shot, leading you into the otherworldliness of it all, that is, a function of the film, a dream guide in the abstract, and a common trope; two, if inside the plot, that is, diegetic, she might be related here as there to Jenna Malone and thus be being used by her to further spook Eden into knowing she is somehow being stalked; or three, this is a hotel, in a horror movie, that means a haunted hotel, and in a haunted hotel since 1980, that means scary little girls
This latter suggests, and this would not be such a bad idea, that this posh hotel, are we in Atlanta? is situated on the site of an old plantation, maybe the original historical one of the one being reproduced in the movie, where a little girl still haunts. Nonetheless, its presence as a trope here, while provocative, is, alas, incidental, nothing much comes of it, except to make of it one more breadcrumb on the trail of stalking that Jenna Malone is springing on her.
Later, there is another picture of the plantation, same one,
and, as if also to flip the opening sequence, Eden is now the belle of the ball, more picture play, ok by me
then the girls go out, have a strange time, then that’s over
after being picked up by Uber it turns out that Malone is driving the car, with the music up, and the overseer is at work too
she is abducted
now, if you were following closely, this plot, that, people with mad obsessions abducting people to use to them fulfill their needs, it is a common trope, I mean, it goes waaaay back to One Body Too Many (1935), for example, when Lugosi abducted brides to use their blood to make his wife young again. But in this case I think the director team, while some of the facile or incidental hinting at tropes might have been read by critics as simply poor characterization and not sly hints, made use of Blackness, and the climate of wokeness which has foregrounded Blackness, to divert our attention away from the possibility that as a highly successful black businesswoman goes about her business in the world, there is not only microaggressions, but also a stalker and her husband actively trying to abduct her back into their mad fantasy world, so, I concede, while I was stirred by these hints, I did not pick it up.
Then, she goes back, she as if wakes up startled from a dream again, but this time she wakes back up into “1860”.
Two things. This COULD be a case of two women, somehow linked to each other, who have nightmares consisting of each other’s lives, imagined across 150 years, is it possible to have epigenetic dreams? and would this be an example. A woman slave in 1860 has nightmare dreams foretelling of her great great great great granddaughter’s life running into problems, and, for that, she then transmits that dream to that granddaughter who then makes the connection by having nightmares of her 4th great grandmothers agonies in her nightmare life. It’s possible. In both cases, however, these are not leaping dreams, leaving the person sitting bolt upright in bed, these are shallower, wake up startled dreams, bottoming out at the level of the symbolic, which, for me, might mean that they do not have the punch, or the shock value, that would make plausible the idea that they traveled in time.
Two. In Octavia Butler’s Kindred (1979), there is no question that she travels back in time, that is, there is a definite chronologically based travel from the hippie era to the civil war era. The means by which this happened though was not a dream, but a kind of dizzy spell, which pulled her back. But she did not know when it would hit, she had no control of it and dreaded it. So, somehow, it was some sympathetic force in time itself, which hooked her and pulled her back and forth in time. I wished Butler would have further explored exactly what these dizzy spells entailed, but she preferred to treat the nodes of the spectrum, not the core passage.
It was at this point that the movie tosses us a curve ball, the general goes out to answer his cellphone.
Wait, what? but, in the rules of time travel sci fi, if the movie is grounded in real 1860 then the cell phone might be one of those technologies that people back in time do not understand when the hero brings it with him back in time. By some pull, he is pulling back technology from his time too. But, it’s weird.
But, in any case, this being pulled back in is different this time because it seems Eden has decided hell no almost immediately, she plans to leave, now. his is prompted by the other girl committing suicide, and as the movie flips and flips back and forth across the time line she is shown not in her bikram but in a poorly built hut in slave days, still, however, according to visual trope, Venetian blinds bespeaking a world of shady doings
Another point. Because, precisely because the movie keeps coming back over the in-between, from today to the past, from the nightmare to the fantasy life of a popular author, while if merely incidental visual rhymes like this could be accused of pingponging in a trollish way–troll pingpong image formalism a plague upon our times–when there is something more; then it is actually true that the imagery is eisentoptic, that is, it actively moves over the in-between, and the visual shot is a function of the movement. When, indeed, the camera pulls back from this shot, to only see the fragment of her hanging in a window
it keeps pulling back,
almost to obliterate it, or reduce it to a no big deal, happens every day in slave quarters living; it keeps pulling back,
then we get to Eden in the fields, and she has that blank look on her face again, like she is there, but not there, aware of something not right, or absolutely sure of it, but uncertain how to proceed,
This sort of visual sequence reinforces the fact that, in fact, this is NOT a dream, but a real experience, that is, this morning, that women in her 19th century slave wear was dressed to the nines giving a lecture on empowerment, and now, next day, she is back in the field in some abduction nightmare by a psycho couple who have taken their hate of what the world did to them out on black people, this posits this back and forth relation as more akin to, if not actually, lucid dreaming, that is, Eden is aware of this being a nightmare, because it is not one. But that is what the visual sequence says, there is, here, double awareness. An accent is placed on this, informing us, in fact, of this fact, even if we have not realized it yet, when the camera crawls out of the rows of cotton
up to the sky; the plot suggestion here is that Eden has decided tonight is the night, because it will be a clear night, with a full moon to guide us,
and the directors assure us, they all know, they are not stupid, but like hostages in a hostage situation they are playing out their hostage speeches, to survive this mess.
this also adds a vividness to this framed view of the idyll she wants to escape from, she is waiting at the window for night to fall, shots like this struck me as almost suggesting we were in a lucid dream, that is, that she knew was dreaming, or in a nightmare, once again, she is vacant, not there, thinking herself ahead of the game, This shot made me highly suspicious however, I kind of stopped, to wonder at it.
its beautiful framing made me think of a similar shot in Nomadland, when Fern looks out upon her foreign world
such shots correspond to a trope I have identified, the Raven’s Gate. It is an inside out POV, but from a person who is out. It is not unlike the shot of Veronica Carlson in Frankenstein Must be Destroyed (1970), aware by her husband’s crime that she is cast out from normalcy, and will ever after that live outside, looking back in at life. It is like the spin in the Black House construct, which I have found in Blackcoat’s Daughter
and in Franco’s Count Dracula (1972), and in Rabid (1977)
it means that life is going on without you perfectly fine, and you only see the negation and emptiness of it, it is an ambient view, gazing out past it: and it may be a criticism that the directors played this blank stare card once too often, bringing the charge upon Monae that she was not up to it as a character, but throughout she was a “figure” of a survival strategy in a nightmare,
so Eden decides tonight, she cannot sleep.
Another word. In Kindred, Butler wrote that when a slave woman was taken by a white master she usually ended up leaving the slave quarters and sleeping up in the same room, maybe even the same bed as the master. As in Mandingo (1972), slave women were reduced almost to the status of being sexual bed warmers to provide comfort to the men. It is therefore weird that she sleeps with the general, or whoever he is, in what looks like a slave quarter house. Why is he there? But, moreso, she does not like this arrangement at all.
I have of late been looking more carefully at how in horror movies hauntings around a bed are measured by the extent to which they express the anxiety of a body with nine openings. Lying your head down on the mattress, without the pillow, is a prostration pose, indicating bereftness and forlornness. It could be said it is a type of the Kong foot type of light sleep paralysis, where you are laid low by stress. You can’t get to sleep, but you don’t want to wake up either. She is huddled in on herself, then, in rejection of the monster on the other side of the bed, her master.
Anyways, night falls, and she is in her nightgown, and he is sleeping in bed next to her.
we have already seen the full moon and we are going to see it at least five more times during this escape sequence, it bespeaks that a change is happening, something magic or evil,
and then she puts her plan into action. Her position in bed is this,
she has no problem with the Empty Pillow haunting her, in fact, she wants the Empty Pillow, she does not want him in her bed, and sleeps almost in protest with him. When he looks over at his side of the bed she sees not a man she loves but an interloper who has taken her hostage in bed. Since in the Raven’s Gate one peers through the emptiness to stir up a Death Mask, one also sees in the entoptic agitation of it Pillowie, the demon of the pillows pretending to be a person; the Bear Hug, a large black presence impassable, suffocating; Wrink, even wrinkles becomes as if demons; Splitface, a kind of death mask in descent that splits in touching down; and then there is even the Angel of Death (all demons I’ve named) . Let’s just say that this unwanted presence in her bed has incorporated all of the phantoms of a Death Mask, to spell death to her if she cannot break free. But the key thing, in terms of escaping, unlike in The Invisible Man, is that he seems to have a psychotic power over her, then seems to be a very light sleeper, ever watchful of her, so she cannot make a noise. Thus, in the darkness of this Raven’s Gate, so many of the moves by which a person gets up and out of bed to explore this or that in a gown prowl are not open to her, she has to be slier. It seems that if she crawl over him, that would wake him up. If she just got up on her side of the bed and walked around, that would wake him up. If she moved at all on the floor, with all of its creaks, that would wake him up. No, his waking up is so dangerous to her plan she cannot wake him up. While she might’ve killed him, her awake, him asleep, she doesn’t. She just wants to get away.
So, she is even under the slant of the roof, totally stuck and cornered in bed with another (a feeling I have felt, so this is nicely placed)
in a rather mechanistic gesture as if to force herself to treat this as a regimen she checks if he is sleeping by fanning her hand over his nose and mouth
So, she flips. She quietly gets up on her knees, on her side of the bed, roughly at the level of her knees, then reaches across his body to the far or his edge of the bed, to take hold
and then after she secures that position, she next carefully puts her hands down on the floor
now the fun thing here is, besides the fact that she felt lying on him below the knees would not wake him, she glances over to the wall to help her at this moment, as if to steel herself to undertake a body movement not at all easy
she gets encouragement from childrens’ drawings, reminding her of her daughter, and a plane, and maybe this gave her the idea, she recreated it here in secret to keep the faith, nice touch.
it IS a copy of the drawing in her hotel room, so is currently serving her as a kind of totem of encouragement (every parent chooses these from the wonders their children draw), which means this visual is an extension of picture play, the odd detail being that the daughter’s wish for a life in house looks a bit like the plantation
and then in a wide arc, she flips; completely standing on her head (the movie fudges on how much of her this would expose)
then on her planted hands pivot quietly to let her body flip over hers too and land softly on a spot on the floor she has pretested as not creaking
well, she did that part, she exhales
My response was all in, at this point, this movie became a horror movie, taking place in the wiggle room of horror, in so far as she undertook this “escape movie” crooked path to escape a menace so menacing that his presence demanded it and that he not be woken. I think of how Max von Sydow did his escapin, in the Night Visitor (1971), Shawshank, many other movies like this. The Crooked Path as a trope is, in effect, the Far Path, but as made crooked by obstacles, forcing it to wobble about or zig zag to some other form. It usually arches over the whoosh, to avoid the whoosh, because that is too dangerous.
this is when the movie came alive for me, as I posted.
it is also coincidentally weird that I come across this strange bed slip the same week as I watched Saint Maud (2021), to study her floating
and then too there is Blake’s Antaeus, who lifts Dante across the devil’s hole into hell.
Now in the language of horror, the fact that in her maneuver she ended up going over the sleeper next to her means that she entered his hover space.
this created the opportunity for a close encounter face to face, her to him, like Alien to Ripley, but not this time. Usually a hover dream floats and circles, like in Blake.
but lower forms, as I have also studied this week, as in this print of Erysichthon being cursed with hunger, it comes in low, and it covers rather than hovers.
From either space a nightmare can be waged. But, she flips out over that, to avoid communicating with his masquerade space, hoping to have stayed clear. So, that is fun, a proning situation in which she knows of the masquerade capacity of his body to suspect movement around him, even when he sleeps, and she figured out a way, from sleeping in bed next to him, to circumvent.
Then, the second thing is to get down to the floor on the other side she has to contort herself. This entails, first, the move, then, second, the standing upside down, and then, third, the flip over onto her feet away from the bed, leave her facing him.
the movie fudged a bit on the legs up in the air part because such a move in pantieless 1860 with only a nightgown on would’ve exposed her below, a sign of death in movies, and making of her, if she stands beside the bed, her vulva as her face, that is, upside down, a kind of Watcher demon, very dangerous, more so if with the face of a vulva. So, in making this flip, she flips, in terms of the language of masquerades of hauntings by bedsides, into a demonic position, especially if it denuded her.
then, making the flip, to then end up flipped, this one pleases me because it all but leaves her looking like she is about to spiderwalk away, again, this is a DEMONIC pose.
and so this is the spiderwalk demon, suggesting she might still spring back on him and attack him.
but, it does not end, after that, when a demon is known, we usually hear that its bones crack, and it crunchily, jerkily assumes full size and moves toward you, saw this analyzing the Annabelle movies this week (from Annabelle Creation)
In her case, here is where what she was doing on the floor comes in, she was, all this time, testing the floor for creaks so that she could find a trail of hard spots across the floor to get out without a creak that would wake him, again, the assumption being as a wary hostage-taking sleeper (a trope going back to the 39 Steps), he is a very light sleeper who will hear every creak. This is pretty wonderful, and the concentration which she poured into this strange little project clearly marks her strategy of escape as relying on the crooked path.
there is almost a dance here, there is a sexual element, as, again, in the stretch it is implied she is partly exposed, but, in general, formally, she is moving like a demon, but overriding the conventions with an aversive purpose, so on the crooked path she is pushing back against an attack.
then she is out, in absolute silence
then, Bush and Renz doing some nice work here, it….gets better. End of part 2.